Love Me Tender, Love Me Sweet: Elvis's Banana Pudding
Monday, August 31, 2009 
When it comes to Elvis and food, undoubtedly you're going to think of his famous favorite sandwich, comprised of peanut butter, fried bacon, banana, and (depending on who you ask) honey, all nestled between slices of white bread and prepared in a griddle, grilled cheese style.
I know. With a dish like that associated with your name, you practically don't need to do anything else in life.
But Elvis did.
Not only did he give us a plethora of musical hits and aforementioned sandwich, but as part of his legacy he also gave us an intensely creamy, meringue-topped banana pudding. Apparently, it was part of the Graceland doctrine that a batch this pudding be prepared nightly; as rumor has it, the King would mash up various pills in it (although if they were a pick-me-up or come-down, I don't know). Of course, I learned this all from the best possible source: a postcard from Graceland from one of my oldest friends.
A banana pudding so craveable immediately had me intrigued, and of course I made up a batch right away. I cut the original recipe in half and omitted the meringue topping (the egg whites can be frozen for later use); it seemed to work out fine, and yielded an unbelievably creamy and rich pudding. While I think I still prefer the Magnolia Bakery banana pudding, this one definitely wins points for its rich history and taste.
Elvis's Banana Pudding (With Some Liberties Taken)
- 2 large (or three small) ripe bananas
- 4 eggs, separated
- 1 1/4 cups sugar
- 1/8 lb butter
- 3 cups milk
- 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
- 1 1/2 tablespoons cornstarch
- About half a box of Nilla Wafers
1. In a large saucepan, mix together the milk, egg yolks, sugar, cornstarch and butter and cook over medium heat until mixture thickens (for me, this was about 25 minutes--but you've got to be watching it the whole time). Add vanilla.
2. In a medium (9x13 inch) pyrex pan or similarly sized baking pan, layer the bananas and wafers.
Reader Comments (15)
omg this looks wonderful!
I love me some banana pudding. I didn't know Elvis was a fan. This looks yummy. Thanks for passing the recipe along!
Oh, banana pudding is one of my favorite things. Yours looks terrific!
I heart banana pudding! I'll have to try the "King's" version some time.
Thanks for sharing,
{ Lindsey }
http://greatfullday.blogspot.com
I love those retro recipes and now a banana pudding of the king... hmmm looks good! thanks for sharing
I love Graceland's recipe collection, almost as much as I love vanilla wafers!
Wow, I've never seen anything like this but will be buying some bananas and getting into the kitchen pronto! Great pics.
AAAHHH, The King!!!!! I'm surprised he didn't put crispy bacon bits in his version!
Btw, anyone who blogs about The King becomes my favorite blogger, no contest.
That's some good stuff for sure!
Mmmm, I am going to have to make that. But if you enjoy a good banana pudding you must try this recipe from Paula Dean. It's super easy, super rich, and super delicious!
http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/paula-deen/not-yo-mamas-banana-pudding-recipe/index.html
I love the checkerboard of 'nanner and 'nillas!
oh my goodness! I'm so glad I found your blog!!! One of my new favorites! This recipe looks too good to be true!
Happy Baking to you :)
Mini Baker
This reminds me so much of the banana custard that we used to have as kiddies in the UK!
Oh, nom, nom, nom!
I cannot wait to make this :)
Banana pudding seems in season because for some reason it reminds me of back-to-school, though I have no memory of eating banana pudding while I was in school. Curious. Thanks for sharing my freezing egg whites tip; it works like a charm!