The Ultimate Guide to Pudding
Monday, March 30, 2015 What is pudding? Seriously. I'm not joking.
Whether or not you woke up this morning thinking you'd get an extreme pudding education (EPE), well, you're gonna get it. I'm not even going to waste time: let's get right into it.
What is Pudding?
The word pudding is believed to come from the French boudin, originally from the Latin botellus, meaning "small sausage", referring to encased meats used in Medieval European puddings
When it comes to defining what pudding is, it can be tricky because depending on where you grew up, the first image that comes to mind might be either a creamy variety served in a packet with a foil top, or it might be something baked in a pan. Or, it might be a catchall term for a variety of desserts.
I guess I should address what pudding is not: custard or mousse. But why not?
Pudding, custard, and mousse: what's the dif?
If you want a full analysis, check out my post on the subject; meantime, I will summarize here.
In America, at least, the key difference is egg--or lack thereof. Pudding does not have to have egg, although it sometimes does.
Custard, on the other hand, depends on egg. According to Professional Baking, custard is “a liquid thickened or set by the coagulation of egg protein.”
As Chow.com aptly put it,
It's not quite as simple as saying, “If it has eggs it’s custard; if it has starch it’s pudding.”Professional Baking points out that there is an overlap: Cream puddings, it says, use a custard base but are thickened with starch. Pastry cream (the stuff you find in an éclair) is a cream pudding—a custard-pudding hybrid.
Mousse is also differentiated by its egg content--typically egg whites--and the fact that it's whipped to form a frothy, light mixture. However, bets can be off because mousse is sometimes made with cream and no egg whites.
So, to summarize:
- Pudding is usually thickened with starch.
- Custard is usually thickened with egg.
- Mousse is whipped, with either egg whites or cream.
But ultimately, there are blurred lines. Some puddings are vigorously mixed in a way that could be considered "whipped"; other puddings contain egg. So, it's fair that some recipes could be on the fence or straddle different creamy dessert worlds.
Pudding is interesting too because it has been assigned to far more than say, chocolate pudding. It can be used to define dishes as widely varied as banana nilla wafer pudding, steamed, cake-like figgy pudding, or even savory Yorkshire pudding. So, to make it a little easier on you, I've taken it upon myself to create three distinct types of pudding:
The three primary types of pudding (according to me)
Very scientific, believe me.
Creamy / boiled
I say "creamy" rather than "boiled" first, because the creamy variety in my mind covers a variety of puddings, from an old fashioned chocolate pudding made on the stovetop to the instant pudding that you make in a jell-o style packet.
Here are just a few examples of creamy puddings.
- Butterscotch
- Chocolate
- Pistachio
- Rice
- Tapioca
- Vanilla
Baked or steamed puddings
Baked puddings are any sort that you'd put in the oven. I'm pputting "steamd" in the same category because most steamed puddings are made in the oven these days, in a water bath. This could be a banana nilla wafer type pudding, or even a bread pudding.
Here are some of the types of baked puddings.
- Bread pudding
- Elvis' favorite banana pudding
- Figgy pudding
- Rice pudding * (yep - it can be boiled or baked!)
Savory
Photo via Flickr member zoyachubby
Savory puddings can be either a boiled or baked variety, but they're made with savory foods. One notable example is Yorkshire pudding, which is made from mixing roast beef drippings with flour and spices and baking it up into a firm form. It really does taste a whole lot better than it sounds. Steamed pies consisting of a filling completely enclosed by suet pastry are also known as puddings.
Here are some of the types of savory puddings.
- Black pudding
- White pudding
- Creamed corn
- Haggis
Not to confuse things, but "pudding" in some parts of the world can be used as a general term for dessert. For instance, I might say "goodies" referring to a number of different sweet foodstuffs in the USA; in the UK, "pudding" could refer to any number of sweet treats served after mealtime.
All the puddings in the world
I've taken some time to put together a guide to every type of pudding I could find, from the USA and far beyond. If I've missed something, please feel free to chime in!
Ashure
Photo via Flickr member bergie
Type: Boiled
What it is: Ashura is a holiday in Turkey signifying the day Noah's ark reached dry land. The festivities, which focus on community, last for a month. Also known as "Noah's Pudding", ashure is symbolic of the first meal Noah enjoyed after leaving the ark. It includes grains, fruits, and nuts. Recipe here.
Asida
Type: Boiled
What it is: A Middle Eastern dish which translates, roughly, to "boiled flour pudding". Recipe here.
Banana pudding
Type: Boiled, steamed, or baked
What it is: A dessert with a vanilla mixture scented with banana slices, often layered with nilla wafers. It's topped with whipped cream or a baked meringue mixture sometimes. Elvis's favorite. Recipe here.
Bánh chuối
What it is: A banana bread pudding (banana and bread, not banana bread) from Vietnam. Recipe here.
Bebinca
Photo via Flickr member the fernandeses
Type: Steamed / baked
What it is: A Goan specialty made with coconut milk. But here's the thing: it has many layers. Officially magic! Recipe here.
Black pudding
Type: Savory
What it is: A classic addition to the full breakfast, this is a sausage made from pig blood from the UK
Blancmange
Type: Boiled, creamy
What it is: One of the standards, invented in France (of course). Cream or milk, sugar, and thickening agent. Recipe here.
Black rice pudding
;)
Type: Creamy, boiled
What it is: Black pudding is served with a rich coconut cream and bananas. I had it often in Bali. Recipe here.
Box pudding
Type: Creamy, boiled (sometimes)
What it is: A powdered mix to which you simply add milk and it becomes pudding. There are slow cook varieties (combine mix with milk, and heat on the stovetop) or instant varieties (combine milk and pudding mix, and stir; it magically thickens). Boxed pudding mix has uses beyond making pudding, though. I can be employed to make very moist cakes, or even to make the middle layer of Nanaimo bars.
Bread and butter pudding
Photo via Flickr member avlxyz
Type: Baked
What it is: A classic UK treat. Buttered bread (or in the case of the fancied-up version above, pannettone) is layered with raisins into a dish, and then a cream and egg mixture is poured on top. It's baked up and then served. Recipe here.
Bread pudding
Type: Creamy, baked / steamed
What it is: A very clever way to use up stale bread. Basically it involves soaking the bread in some sort of cream mixture; sometimes it's baked, sometimes not. Recipe here.
Brown betty
Type: Baked / steamed
What it is: A mixture of breadcrumbs, apples, and plenty of sugar. It's said to date to Colonial times, and it tastes better than its humble ingredients might imply. Recipe here.
Butterscotch pudding
Photo via Flickr member onlinepastrychef
Type: Boiled, creamy
What it is: A creamy pudding characterized by brown sugar, which gives it a rich, full taste. Not that you asked, but one of my favorites. Recipe here.
Cabinet Pudding
See: bread and butter pudding. This is a variation with cake instead of bread, and featuring alcohol-soaked fruit. Recipe here.
Chireta
See: Haggis. This is a Spanish version. Recipe here.
Chocolate pudding
Type: Boiled / baked / creamy
What it is: A pudding made with chocolate (well, that was easy). But there are many different types, from the Swiss Miss sort to baked varieties and homemade boiled types. Here's but one mere recipe, but there are many.
Chocolate biscuit pudding
Type: Boiled
What it is: a traditional Sri Lankan dessert consisting of moistened biscuits (the cookie kind) and chocolate pudding. Sometimes topped with nuts. It looks awesome to me! Recipe here.
Christmas pudding
Photo via Flickr member riggott
Type: Steamed / baked
What it is: Made with brandy-soaked fruit and treacle. Some suggest, for dynamic serving, to light it on fire before digging in, which I think is optional. It's the fire that makes it cooler than fruitcake, I think. Recipe here.
Coconut pudding
Type: Boiled
What it is: A coconut milk mixture thickened with gelatin and allowed to firm in molds. I'm told it's a popular dim sum dessert. Recipe here.
Cottage pudding
Type: Baked / boiled
What it is: A cake which is served with a generous amount of vanilla pudding sauce, which thickens the cake and makes it nice and moist. Recipe here.
Clootie
Type: Steamed / baked
What it is: A large pudding which is steamed in a sort of dumpling-like shape. "Clootie" apparently refers to "little cloth", ostensibly what the pudding is steamed in. Filled with raisins, dates, golden syrup. Made with suet. A traditional treat in Scotland. Recipe here.
Corn pudding
Type: Baked
What it is: Not to be confused with creamed corn, this is a baked side dish with corn, cream, and sometimes even cornmeal added to thicken the mixture. Recipe here.
Creamed corn
Type: Boiled, creamy
What it is: A mixture of cream and corn which is thickened to a gooey, slightly sweet mixture. Personally I don't know why it's considered a dinner dish when it's so sweet it could be a breakfast mush. Recipe here.
Creme caramel
Type: Steamed/baked
What it is: The European version of flan. A thick custard baked with caramel on the bottom, which is flipped before serving. Recipe here.
Diplomat pudding
Type: Steamed, baked
What it is: French. A steamed mixture of bread or ladyfingers, milk, fruits, and seasonings which looks quite cake-like once finished. Recipe here.
Diplomatic pudding
Type: Steamed, baked
What it is: Not to be confused with the French version, this one is Cuban, but otherwise somewhat similar to Diplomat pudding. Recipe here.
Dock pudding
Type: Savory, boiled
What it is: Leaves and nettles are combined with oats, onions, and seasonings to make this unique savory pudding. Recipe here.
Dutch baby
Type: Baked / steamed
What it is: Like Yorkshire pudding, but made without meat drippings. Recipe here. Peanut butter recipe here.
Figgy duff
Type: Steamed
What it is: A classic Newfoundland treat. In spite of its name, it contains no figs, but rainsins instead. Recipe here.
Figgy Pudding
Type: Steamed / baked
What it is: A fig, breadcrumb, and spice mixture which is baked in a water bath. Recipe here.
Flan
See: Creme caramel. Recipe here.
Flummery
Type: Boiled
What it is: A thickened mixture of stewed fruit which is served with cream. Originally from the UK, but you can find it in retro cookbooks in the US, too. Recipe here.
Frumenty
Type: Boiled
What it is: A thick, cracked wheat type of porridge, which can be boiled or steamed. Per Wikipedia, "hence its name, which derives from the Latin word frumentum, "grain". It dates back to Medieval Europe, where it was apparently served as a side dish alongside meat. Recipe here.
"Goody"
Type: Boiled
What it is: It's as easy as this: bits of bread, torn apart by hand, and served with hot milk, sugar and spices. A simple UK treat and a humble but tasty dessert. Discussed here.
Haggis
Type: Savory
What it is: Stomach, liver, heart...and oats. It's a savory steamed pudding made with animal parts, thickened with oats. An acquired taste from Scotland. Recipe here.
Hasty pudding
Type: Savory or sweet, boiled, baked
What it is: Also known as Indian pudding. A pudding made primarily with cornmeal mush which was dressed up with anything from pork fat to (in more modern days) molasses, raisins, and sweeteners. Recipe (and more info) here.
Haupia
Type: Boiled
What it is: Creamy coconut cubes. This Polynesian treat is made by boiling coconut milk, water, and sugar together and then thickening with cornstarch. Once firm and cooled, it is cut into squares. Recipe here.
Junket
Type: Creamy, boiled
What it is: Basically a shelf-stable version of blancmange, made with rennet. It used to be quite popular but has fallen out of favor. Though you can still find it in supermarkets, I dare you to find someone who's eaten it recently. Recipe here.
Kačamak
Type: Boiled, savory
What it is: Also known as "Fatty Porridge" (best name ever), this savory pudding starts with potatoes, cornmeal, and is dressed up with cheese, cream, and other flavorings. It bears some resemblance to polenta, but is far fattier. You'll find it in eastern Europe. Recipe here.
Kazandibi
Type: Boiled
What it is: Sort of like Turkish creme brulee, but with chicken involved. The name refers to the "bottom of the pot" because that's the portion of the Tavuk göğsü (chicken pudding, below) from where kazandibi comes from. Recipe here.
Keşkül
What it is: A Turkish creation, sort of like rice pudding, but made with flaked almond. Recipe here.
Kheer
Type: Boiled, creamy
What it is: An Indian take on rice pudding, made by boiling basmati rice with milk and seasonings such as cardamom and saffron. Recipe here.
Kulolo
Type: Baked
What it is: A cakey caramelized coconut and taro pudding from Hawaii. Recipe here.
Kutia
Type: Boiled
What it is: An Eastern European recipe which combines wheat berries and simmering milk, and is served dotted with fruits, nuts, and seeds. Recipe here.
Malvern pudding
Type: Boiled / steamed
What it is: A concotion from the UK: a boiled pudding which is poured over apples and then steamed or baked to finish. Recipe here.
Lange vinger pudding
Type: Boiled, creamy
What it is: Lange vinger means "Lady Finger". In this concoction, lady fingers are layered with jam and pudding to make a deliciously stacked dish. Simple recipe here.
Mango Pudding
Type: Boiled, creamy
What it is: Mango pudding is a mainstay at Chinese dim sum restaurants. Made using mangoes and cream, it attains a texture sort of like a pot de creme. Recipe here.
M'halbi
See: Rice pudding. This version is from Algeria. Recipe here.
Noodle pudding
Type: Baked, sweet or savory
What it is: AKA Kugel. A creamy baked pudding made with noodles. A traditional Jewish food. Recipe here.
Orez cu lapte
See: Rice pudding. This version is Romanian. Recipe here.
Panna cotta
Type: Creamy, boiled
What it is: Meaning "cooked cream", this simple Italian dish is made using milk, sugar, gelatin and cream, though it can be dressed up in any number of ways. Recipe here.
Persimmon pudding
Type: Steamed / baked
What it is: Sort of like figgy pudding in construction, this steamed pudding is rich in persimmons, and often served with a "hard sauce" (that means acohol). Recipe here.
Pistachio pudding
Type: Boiled, creamy
What it is: A creamy pudding flavored with pistachios. Also a popular pudding mix, which is greener than any real-life pistachio but very delicious. Recipe here.
Po'e
Type: Baked / steamed
What it is: A Tahitian fruit pudding, made with fruits and thickened with arrowroot and coconut cream. It's traditionally steamed in banana leaves, but can be baked, too. Recipe here.
Put chai ko
Photo via Wikimedia commons
Type: Steamed
What it is: A solid pudding cake from China. Recipe here.
Queen of puddings
Type: Baked /steamed
What it is: A rich pudding confection from the United Kingdom, made with a steamed sweetened breadcrumb mixture, summer fruits, and a rich cream topping. Recipe here.
Rice pudding
Photo via Flickr member bgreenlee
Type: Cross-category. Rice puddings can be creamy/boiled, steamed, or baked. Usually, most people think of a sweet pudding first when they think of rice pudding.
What it is: A pudding which has rice at the base, which acts as body and thickener. It's combined with milk or cream, and often sweetened and scented with cinnamon, nutmeg, etc. In the US, it's a Jewish comfort food; there are variations of the pudding all around the world. Recipe here.
NOTE on Rice pudding: some variations are listed separately here, but here's a nice roundup from Wikipedia of rice pudding variations from around the world.
- Bubur Sumsum (Indonesian)
- Ketan hitam (Indonesian) black glutinous rice porridge
- Tsamporado (Philippines) chocolate rice pudding
- Dudhapak (Gujarati) with slow-boiled milk, sugar, basmati rice, nuts, and saffron
- Firni (Tajik/Afghan/Pakistani/Indian) with broken rice, cardamom and pistachio, reduced to a paste, and served cold
- Kheer (Nepal/Indian/Pakistani) with slow-boiled milk
- Kiribath (Sri Lankan) made with coconut milk
- Moghli (Lebanese) with anise, caraway, and ginger
- Muhalibiyya (Arabic) with milk, rice flour, sugar, and rosewater
- Payasam (South Indian) with slow-boiled milk, sugar/jaggery, and nuts
- Phinni/Paayesh (Bengali) with grounded basmati or parboiled rice, cardamom and pistachio; can be served either hot or cold
- Pulut hitam(Malaysian/Singaporean) similar to ketan hitam, its Indonesian counterpart
- Riz bi haleeb (Eastern) or ruz bil-laban (Egyptian), (lit. "rice-with-milk") (Arab) with rosewater and occasionally mastic
- Shir-berenj/ (Tajik, Afghan, and Iranian)
- Shola-e zard (Tajik, Afghan, and Iranian) with saffron
- Şorbeşîr (Kurdish) with cinnamon
- Zarda wa haleeb (Iraqi) rice prepared with date syrup served in the same dish as with rice prepared with milk
Rag pudding
Type: Savory, steamed
What it is: A savory steamed pudding made with meat, onions, and potatoes, thickened with flour and enriched with cream or butter. Recipe here.
Red pudding
Type: Creamy, boiled
What it is: Danish in descent, this pudding combines rhubarb, sugar, and tapioca, which are boiled together and then served warm, with cream. Recipe here.
Rødgrød or Rote Grütze
Type: Creamy, boiled
What it is: a sort of slurry made from groats or grits (though some recipes even use semolina or sago, or even potato or corn starch), combined with summer berries. The cereal or "grain" type mixture thickens with the fruit, and sweetened, for a pudding-like consistency. Recipe here.
Roz bil-haleeb
See: Rice pudding. This version is from Lebanon. Recipe here.
Roz de laban
See: Rice pudding. This version is from Egypt. Recipe here.
Rượu nếp
Type: Steamed
What it is: Hailing from Vietnam, this version of rice pudding is made with glutinous rice which has been fermented (often with yeast) and then steamed in a banana leaf. Recipe here.
Sago pudding
Type: Baked
What it is: A pudding made with sago (not totally unlike tapioca) and milk, sugar and other seasonings. I've seen recipes noted as being South African and Australian, so I'm not sure where the dish is from. Recipe here.
Scrapple
Photo via Flickr member accidentalhedonist
Type: Savory, baked/steamed
What it is: A Philadelphia and Pennsylvania Dutch tradition: sort of pork and bread crumb mush, made with onions or other seasonings. Typically served at breakfast. Recipe here.
Spoon bread
Type: Baked, savory (sometimes)
What it is: A thick pudding / souffle made with cornmeal which sometimes errs sweet, sometimes savory. It's often cooked in a casserole dish and served as a side, as cornbread would be. Recipe here.
Spotted dick
Photo via Flickr member caveman
Type: Steamed/baked
What it is: The most likely pudding name to induce tittering. In this UK classic, a fruit and currant (those are the "spots") steamed pudding is served with a thick custard sauce. In my opinion, that's what makes it. Recipe here.
Sticky toffee or toffee date pudding
Type: Steamed/baked
What it is: A fairly normal steamed pudding becomes a British classic when smothered with a sticky toffee sauce. Sticky date pudding is pretty much the same, but with dates mixed in. Recipe here.
Summer pudding
Type: Steamed, boiled
What it is: A concoction hailing from the UK composed of white bread, berries, juices, and currants. The bread turns pink and soft thanks to the summer berries, which give the pudding its name. Recipe here.
Superpudding
Type: Boiled
What it is: Instant pudding made with pudding instead of milk. Amazing! Also invented by me. Recipe here.
Sussex pond pudding
Type: Steamed
What it is: A steamed, moist pudding from the UK that oozes liquid when cut into--hence the "pond" reference. Recipe here.
Sütlaç
Type: Creamy, boiled, or baked
What it is: A creamy Turkish rice pudding which is sometimes boiled, sometimes baked. Recipe here.
Tapioca pudding
Type: Creamy, boiled
What it is: A boiled pudding made using tapioca pearls (derived from starchy tubers) combined with cream or milk, eggs, and sugar. Recipe here.
Tavuk göğsü - in my opinion, the weirdest one on the list.
Photo via Wikimedia commons
Type: Savory, boiled
What it is: A delicacy in Turkey, made with chicken and milk. But--wait for it--it's sweetened and served as dessert. This officially makes it the first dessert I've ever seen made with chicken. Recipe here.
Teurgoule
Photo via Flickr member ulikleafear
Type: Creamy, boiled
What it is: A rice pudding hailing from Normandy, France. Composed of rice cooked with milk and sugar, and scented with cinnamon and nutmeg.
Tiết canh
Type: Savory
What it is: A Vietnamese "pudding" from thickened blood and meat. Read more here.
Treacle sponge pudding
Type: Baked /steamed
What it is: A British treat made by combining eggs, sugar, flour, and the usual suspects with a generous amount of golden syrup, then steaming until it makes a spongey, cakey steamed pudding. Recipe here.
Vanilla pudding
Photo via Flickr member bochalla
Type: Creamy, or steamed/baked
What it is: A pudding scented with vanilla beans or extract for a vanilla-rich flavor. Vanilla pudding is not only a type of pudding, but a canvas. Any type of flavor can be added to it, from nutella to peanut butter to cappuccino to...well, let your mind go wild! Recipe here.
Watalappam
;)
Photo via Wikimedia commons
Type: Steamed
What it is: A pudding popular in Sri Lanka, made with coconut milk, eggs, and sugar. Recipe here.
White pudding
Photo via Flickr member Bob Walker
Type: Savory, baked
What it is: A savory "pudding" composed of oatmeal, suet, and minced liver. It's a variation on black pudding, and is served at breakfast in Scotland or Ireland. Recipe here.
Yorkshire pudding
Photo via Flickr member zoyachubby
Type: Savory, baked
What it is: A baked pudding which starts with beef drippings which are augmented by flour, eggs, and flavorings. They can be served popover-style or like a big pancake. Served as a side dish alongside savory meat dishes. Recipe here.
Zerde
Type: Creamy, boiled
What it is: A boiled rice pudding hailing from Turkey, scented with saffron, which gives it a unique yellow color. Recipe here.
Reader Comments (3)
Keebly: thanks, I will check it out and add!